What Happens When an Employee Fails a Right to Work Check? A Comprehensive Guide

WhatHappens When an Employee Fails a Right to Work Check?

When an employee fails a right to work check, it can lead tosevere legal consequences. Employers could face civil penalties up to£20,000 per illegal worker, potential criminal prosecution, and evenloss of sponsor license. Employees must have valid work documents,cooperate with checks, and be informed of failure reasons. Employers need toinvestigate thoroughly, consider reasons behind the failure, and carefullyhandle disciplinary actions. Seeking legal advice is important to guaranteecompliance with immigration laws. Understanding these implications is essentialto navigate through this challenging situation.

If the right to work check was done as part of a BPSS Check then failing your Right to Work check will also mean you will not get BPSS Clearance. 

LegalImplications of Failing Right to Work Check

Thelegal ramifications of failing a Right to Work check are significant,encompassing civil penalties, criminal prosecution, and potentialloss of sponsor license for employers. When an employer fails toguarantee that their employees have the legal right to work in the UK, they canface civil penalties of up to £20,000 per illegal worker. This financialconsequence can be detrimental to the business's bottom line. Additionally,employers may also be subject to criminal prosecution if found to be employingindividuals without the right to work, leading to further legal troubles andpotential damage to the company's reputation.

Inaddition to the financial and criminal implications, failing to comply withright to work regulations can result in the loss of the employer's sponsorlicense. This loss can have far-reaching consequences, affecting the business'sability to hire non-UK workers in the future. Hence, it is important foremployers to conduct thorough right to work checks and ensure compliance with immigrationlaws to avoid these severe legal repercussions.

Employee Rights andResponsibilities

Inthe domain of employment obligations and entitlements, employees are taskedwith upholding specific responsibilities to guarantee compliance with rightto work regulations. It is the employee's duty to confirm that they possessvalid and updated right to work documents, providing them to their employerbefore expiration to maintain their employment status. Additionally, employeesmust cooperate with any necessary checks or investigations conducted bytheir employer to verify their right to work in the country.

Moreover,in the event an employee fails a right to work check, they have theright to be informed of the reasons for the failure and to provide anyrelevant information or documentation to clarify their status. It is essentialfor employees to be mindful of their rights throughout this process and to seeklegal advice if needed to understand their options and potentialconsequences. By fulfilling these responsibilities, employees can activelycontribute to a fair and transparent resolution of any right to work issuesthat may arise.

Employer's InvestigationProcess

Upondiscovery of an employee failing a right to work check, employers mustpromptly initiate a thorough investigation into the individual's workauthorization status.

Thisinvestigation should encompass verifying the employee's original right towork documents and reviewing any potential changes in their immigrationstatus that may have led to the failure of the check. Employers mustcarefully consider the reasons behind the failed right to work check beforeproceeding with any further actions.

It isessential for employers to follow a critical and detailed process during theinvestigation, ensuring that all relevant information is gathered and assessedobjectively. Seeking legal advice is highly recommended to guaranteecompliance with both employment law and immigration regulations when handlingemployees who fail right to work checks.

DisciplinaryActions and Terminations

Initiatingdisciplinary measures following an employee's failure in a right to work checkrequires a meticulous and fair approach to address the compliance issueeffectively. When handling disciplinary actions and terminations in such cases,employers must proceed cautiously to guarantee fairness and legality.

Hereare some key points to keep in mind:

          Conduct a thoroughinvestigation into the employee's right to work documentation.

          Hold a meeting with theemployee to discuss the failure and allow them to provide any relevantinformation.

          Take into account all possibleoutcomes, including termination, within the boundaries of fair dismissalreasons.

          Provide the employee with anopportunity to appeal the decision, especially in cases of termination due toright to work concerns.

Ensuring Fairness inHandling Cases

Ensuringfairness and consistency in handling cases where an employee fails a rightto work check is paramount for employers. When faced with such a situation,it is essential to conduct a thorough investigation into thecircumstances surrounding the failed check before making any decisions.

Holdinga meeting with the employee to discuss the issue allows them to provide anyrelevant information that could potentially impact the outcome. Throughout theprocess, employers must maintain importance, reasonableness, and consistency touphold the integrity of the dismissal procedure.

It isalso essential for employers to have a statutory excuse defense in placein case of unintentional unlawful employment resulting from a failed check. Byfollowing an important and diligent approach, employers can ensure thatthey are making informed and just decisions when addressing cases ofemployees failing right to work checks.

Repercussions for Employers

Employersmust grasp the gravity of non-compliance and take proactive steps to guaranteethey meet their legal obligations regarding right to work checks. Employersfailing to establish a statutory excuse through right to work checks can incurcivil penalties of up to £20,000 per illegal worker. The repercussions foremployers who do not comply with right to work regulations are severe and canhave lasting consequences.

Here are somekey repercussions that employers may face:

          Civil Penalties: Fines of up to £20,000 per illegal worker.

          Home Office Site Visits: Inspections to verify compliance, which can lead to penalties ifdocumentation is not in order.

          Criminal Prosecution: Risk of legal action, imprisonment, and unlimited fines forknowingly hiring individuals without the right to work.

          Reputational Damage: Potential harm to the company's reputation, as businesses foundhiring illegal workers are publicly named in Home Office reports.

Seeking ProfessionalAssistance

Seekingprofessional assistance from immigration lawyers can provide invaluableguidance on managing the complexities of handling employees who fail right-to-workchecks. Immigration specialists possess the expertise to help employersnavigate the legal implications and consequences of such situations. Byseeking professional advice, employers can gain a clear understanding ofthe appropriate steps to take when an employee fails a right-to-work check.

Consultingwith legal experts guarantees that employers follow the correct procedures andavoid potential legal pitfalls that may arise in these circumstances.With the assistance of immigration lawyers, employers can make informeddecisions regarding employees who fail right-to-work checks, helping them touphold compliance with immigration laws and regulations. Professionalguidance in these matters can be instrumental in safeguarding the employer'sinterests while also treating the employees fairly and in accordancewith the law.

Employerscan benefit greatly from the insights and recommendations provided byimmigration lawyers when facing challenges related to employees failingright-to-work checks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Happens ifan Employer Doesn't Check Right to Work?

If an employer fails to check an employee's right to work, they riskfacing severe consequences, including:

          Civil penalties of up to£20,000 per illegal worker.

          Potential loss of statutoryexcuse.

          Negative operational,financial, and reputational impacts.

Non-compliance with right to work checks may lead to:


          Loss of sponsor license.

          Significant financialimplications for businesses.

It is essential for employers to adhere to legal requirements toavoid such repercussions.

What Happens ifYou Employ Someone Without the Right to Work?

Hiring someone without the right to work can have serious legal,financial, and reputational consequences for employers. It is vital forcompanies to verify all employees have the legal right to work in thecountry.

Failing to do so can lead to civil penalties, potential criminalprosecution, and significant fines. It is imperative for employers tofollow proper procedures, conduct thorough checks, and take appropriateaction if an employee is found to lack the right to work.

Can You Lose Your Rightto Work?

Yes, individuals can lose their right to work due to variousreasons such as visa expiration, revocation, or legal changes. It isessential for employers to verify that their employees maintain valid workauthorization.

Regular right to work checks help prevent illegal employment.Employers must handle cases of employees losing the right to work withfairness, conducting investigations and potentially considering terminationwithin legal guidelines. Proper understanding of the situation is key totaking appropriate actions.

What to Do if anEmployee No Longer Has the Right to Work in the Uk?

When an employee no longer has the right to work in the UK,employers must conduct follow-up checks and verify the individual's ongoingright to work status.

It is essential to evaluate each case's unique circumstances andlegal implications before taking any action. Providing support and guidance foraffected employees to apply for new visas before the expiration can helpmitigate risks.

Dismissal should only occur following fair procedures andconsidering alternative reasons if necessary.


To sum up, when an employeefails a Right to Work check, employers must follow a thoroughinvestigation process to determine the circumstances surrounding thefailure.

It is crucial to take intoaccount legal implications, employee rights, and fair treatment throughout thedisciplinary actions or terminations that may follow.

Seeking professionalguidance can help employers navigate this complex situation while ensuringcompliance with employment laws.

Leave Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *